In
August of 2017, I wrote about the topic of e-cigarette tipping points for the
first time. 1st In this article, I return to this topic [2] to see what, if
anything, has changed since then. E-cigarettes claimed to have reached two big
tipping points when the 2017 paper was published. The first was because of
their widespread use, with an estimated 10% of the adult population in the
United States using or having used e-cigarette products [3]. The second had to
do with public perceptions of protection and benefit to public health [4]. I
noted at the time that the American Food and Drug Administration (FDA) was projecting
a harshly negative view of e-cigarette safety, only grudgingly recognizing that
there could be personal and public health benefits. Since then, the FDA and the
broader American tobacco control culture have become so hostile to e-cigarettes
that each product is now facing forced withdrawal from the market unless the
manufacturer can apply a "viable" Pre-Market Tobacco Application as
soon as possible (PMTA). Because of the expense of the studies needed to
prepare the application, as previously mentioned [1], such an application is
physically impossible for 99 percent or more of e-cigarette manufacturers. This
essay will discuss how and why the majority of the e-cigarette industry in the
United States is on its way out, and what, if anything, can be done about it.
Author (s) Details
Joel L. Nitzkin
R Street Institute,
Washington DC, c/o JLN, MD Associates, LLC, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA.
View Book :- https://stm.bookpi.org/CDHR-V7/article/view/925